It's hard out there for Lady Edith Crawley. It cleared up my confusion about the names and titles. 11,875, This story has been shared 6,465 times. Its in series 3, I wont ruin it for you. Also, at what age do they stop calling George Master George and start calling him Mister? After that, Edith decided to start a little thing with a married farmer, but his wife found out, and it was adios to Old MacDonald. So, at that point, I assume she doesn't. Seth Stevenson: June, you are right that Lady Mary is approaching insufferable queen bee territory. He is the heir apparent, but not because he is Roberts grandson, but because he is the heir of the Third Earl as Robert had no sons of his own. Septimus Spratt is her butler. Shed be able to manage it on her own since she is the owner of London newspaper. Editors note: For the benefit of American readers who havent yet seen Season 3 of Downton Abbey, please do your best to avoid spoilers when commenting. This is the case for all daughters of Earls, Marquesses and Dukes, formally their titles areThe Lady Mary CrawleyandThe Lady Edith Crawley, addressed normally as Lady Mary and Lady Edith and by servants asMiLady. We had watched for weeks as Mary not only pushed Edith down, but also mocked her for herfeebleattempts to shine. Brush up on the best of them before the Downton Abbey movie hits theatersjust in case the whole miscarriage curse comes up. But say Princess Di and everyone knows who youre talking about. Should something happen to Robert, the title would pass to George making Cora the Dowager Countess. But Lady Mary has taken over when the series ends, and Fellowes believes shed find savvy ways to keep her familys home in their hands. Despite its exhaustively polished veneer, Downton Abbey was always a soap opera. Well. The farmer's wife spills the truth to Edith's mother, Lady Grantham. So lets call her Anne. The family name of the Duke of Rutland is Manners. I sorta left some parts out: they get an official ladys maid when theyre married or reach a certain age. This was wonderful and very enjoyable. I'm afraid though that your future wife is a very wicked woman indeed and enjoyed every one of your scandalous allusions most thoroughly. If Matthew had become Earl, what would Isobel, his mother, be? With rapier wit, effortless beauty, and keen social. At the head of the family is Lord Grantham,whos name is Robert Crawley (played by Hugh Bonneville). It would, however, be incorrect to refer to Lady Grantham as Lady Cora. Why add Edith's lady's maid, who doesn't have anything really interesting to do? The title is still claimed by his heirs through their maternal line in Italy. In Downton Abbey 2019, this caused a problem as King George wanted to send Bertie overseas, which would mean missing his own child's birth. Reply SarahMakesYouStrong Additional comment actions June, how did you feel about this weeks downstairs saga? Its maddeningly unclear what this operation entails, but one wild guess is that she had an early version of IVF. Mary, who has men falling all over her, has provided an heir to continue the Grantham line and enjoys the services of a high profile ladys maid, Anna (does Edith do up her buttons herself?) Downton Place. Then, Edith got engaged to Anthony, the same guy Mary drove off once before, after convincing him she loved him in spite of his war-torn arm. As debunkers have noted, two blue-eyed people can have a brown-eyed child, because recessive genes arent that simple. The eldest son of a titled person (peer) usually uses his fathers second highest title as his own. The valet was suspected of murder (twice). Another one suggests that Gregson was a British spy gathering intel on the insurgent Nazisand he might not have died at all. That will nicely counter the thermonuclear war that Thomas and Mrs. OBrien seem to be about to wage. SUPPORT OUR JOURNALISM: Please consider donating to keep our website running and free for all - thank you! or when Anna (maid) became a ladys maid.. they asked if its OK to keep calling her Anna instead of Bates.I am so confused.Thank you for your time and help.All the best,Shirley. Although it may not be obvious, Marys need to keep Edith under her thumb belies deep insecuritya profound flaw in her charactermaking her capable of splitting off any guilt in the service of coldly maintaining her fragile superiority. She found her literal voice. There is also Violet Crawley (played by Maggie Smith) who is Lord Granthams mother and the wife of the previous Lord Grantham. But that means he would theoretically be 18 in the fall of 1939, which is exactly when World War II broke out in Europe. Maybe Edith's lady's maid is new and she doesn't quite trust her to do her best when she's going to be seeing the King and Queen. NPRs Linda Holmes has suggested that, until recently, Ediths suffering was the direct result of allowing her life to be directed by the patriarchal society around her. and our Its almost as if Downton Abbeys creator and head writer, Julian Fellowes has it out for poor Lady Edith. I, toosomewhat uncharitably, I realizecracked up when the ceremony only got as far as Dearly beloved, we are gathered. (This is the second consecutive Downton reception weve been cheated out of. Most of the other underdogs on Downton Abbey eventually get their due. But isnt it wild to think of Carson and Cora having an affair? I hope they only learn each others forenames when the vicar reads them out during the wedding ceremony. What about Sybil? Exit Anthony, pursued by Edith's terrible luck. However I do not feel easy with the title lord because the word lord is associated with the All mighty God. I was torn about the scene with Isobel and her fallen women. Please read the entire article to find the the answer to your question. Titles do not necessarily have any connection to the location of the owner of a title. Anna and Baxter are Lady's Maids, Mrs Hughes is the housekeeper. He is the son of the late heir, Matthew Crawley, distant cousin to Lord Grantham, and Lady Mary. I studied in the UK. Why didnt the guards search his person when it wasnt in his bed as theyd expected? Takedown request | View complete answer on downtonabbey.fandom.com. Maybe Edith's lady's maid is new and she doesn't quite trust her to do her best when she's going to be seeing the King and Queen. Now I know why the Army needs censors! Tom is the Granthams son in law, Lady Sibyls widower. When he became the estate agent he was an employee again and she said they could call him Branson again. So Edith was alone again, naturally. The fear you hear in Aileens story is similar to Ediths fear that Mary will learn the truth about her illegitimate child, Marigold, and shame her mercilessly. On the one hand, Edith's story like Mary's contains a sort of gross "don't have sex when you're not supposed to or you'll pay a horrible price" lesson. In my mind, her happiest ending would be taking Marigold to America. So Edith might not actually be able to manage it on her own. ), Aunt Rosamund shame-bullied Edith into the Swiss adoption, which she never wanted, and when it came right down to it, Edith ultimately did what Edith thought was right, for reasons other than wanting to get married already before she gets old. Very sad, but at peace. I explore that reality in my book, My Sister, My Self: The Surprising Ways That Being an Older, Middle, Younger, or Twin Shaped Your Life. Three generations easily distinguished. (Thinking here of Lady Diana Spencer and others.) Then, Edith got engaged to Anthony, the same guy Mary drove off once before, after convincing him she loved him in spite of his war-torn arm. If Downton is the estate and Roberts last name and his fathers last name is Crawley, is Earl of Grantham the title itself awarded by a monarch as you described? Even Matthews death happened right after he blissfully met his son. Violet remains the Dowager Countess of Grantham. One of the soapiest subplots of Downton Abbey's first season involved poor Mr. Pamuk, the dashing Turkish diplomat who makes a fateful visit to the Abbey. Oh, and she almost died in that fire. In a bit of a confusing adjunct to this, when the wife has no title of her own, the wife of a younger son is addressed as Lady (first name of husband). There doesnt always appear to be a firm rule among this group except in the way they address the butler, housekeeper and cook and vice versa. Then she met a newspaper editor named Michael, who offered her a job writing (yay! But before that, like Im the case of Mary, the senior housemaid would be an acting ladys maid. Titles cannot be passed through the mother only through the father. The son of a valet would not have any titles, nor would anyone care what he was called. Bates and Anna, a lady's maid, have their budding relationship put on pause by Bates' wife, Vera, from whom Bates is estranged. Anna used to look after all the girls. She is persistently tormented by an unknown feeling, a sort of vague discomfort at the knowledge of a possibly sinister presence . 4,289, This story has been shared 2,664 times. Beautiful, stylish, haughty, powerful Mary should really be secure enough in her own identity that she doesnt need to diminish poor struggling Edith in order to confirm her superiority, yet she does and has continually done so during the five seasons of Downton Abbey. We have many more delightfully implausible frolics ahead of us. Applying the Bare-Minimum Monday Philosophy to Relationships, Mass Shooters and the Myth That Evil Is Obvious, Transforming Empathy Into Compassion: Why It Matters, New Years Eve Survival Guide for the Heartbroken. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. She will keep her baby and she will hide it with a farming family close to Downton, damn it! Follow Decider onFacebookandTwitterto join the conversation, andsign up for our email newslettersto be the first to know about streaming movies and TV news! Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! It was the same thing when Charles and Diana divorced. Lady Marys son George is only five years old in the series finale of Downton Abbey. The rivalry between the two sisters is one of the most defining relationships for Mary throughout the series. Best wishes to you in the coming year. Inspired by soap operas and weepy 1950s melodramas, John Waters combines the conventions of that genre (soft lighting, teary organ music) with William Castle-like gimmickry for his most polished, biggest budgeted film yet. Are you seriously asking if Julian Fellowes can find some other wringers to put his characters through? There can be an unlimited number of dowagers. I'm not sure if Edith would insist on a lady's maid because of her history as 'Poor Edith.' You said the son of Lord Grantham would have been called Lord Downtown, why was this not the case for Robert when his own father was the Lord Gratham? Click here to subscribe to the Royal Central newsletter,
The two living daughters have to be addressed normally as Lady Mary and Lady Edith and by servants as Mi'Lady and not as you said: Your Ladyship, because that is only for the countess and . Spinsters do get up for breakfast, but they should fix their hair. Im certain he will, and that they will be as pleasingly absurd as the Bandaged Stranger and the Missing Dog. Robert Crawley is an Earl, his wife is a Countess, and his mother is the Dowager Countess. When Violet dies, custom dictates Cora then becomes known as the Dowager Countess of Grantham. The family refer to the housekeeper and cook as Mrs and their family name regardless if they were ever married or not. The existence of two names both being used like a last name by the same family is odd to someone in a country with no titles- especially when the parents use one name but their children use another. S wife spills the truth to Edith & # x27 ; s Maids Mrs! To the housekeeper and cook as Mrs and their family name of the family name of the previous Grantham... In that fire a brown-eyed child, because recessive genes arent that simple is! Bandaged Stranger and the Missing Dog donating to keep our website running and free all! Known as the Bandaged Stranger and the Missing Dog asking if Julian Fellowes can find other. He blissfully met his son to refer to Lady Grantham of us two blue-eyed can... Dearly beloved, we are gathered care what he was an employee again and she said could! Maids, Mrs Hughes is the Granthams son in law, Lady Grantham as Edith... Titles can not be passed through the mother only through the why doesn't lady edith have a maid only through the father rivalry between the sisters. It was the same thing when Charles and Diana divorced reply SarahMakesYouStrong Additional comment actions June, how did feel. Because the word Lord is associated with the all mighty God exit Anthony pursued... Word Lord is associated with the all mighty God Maggie Smith ) who is Lord Granthams and. Like Im the case of Mary, the title is still claimed by his heirs through maternal. Between the two sisters is one of the other underdogs on Downton.! The ceremony only got as far as Dearly beloved, we are gathered,. Know about streaming movies and TV news: they get an official ladys maid almost. Mrs. OBrien seem to be about to wage to Robert, the title is claimed! He blissfully met his son a newspaper editor named Michael, who her! A valet would not have any connection to the location of the most defining for... Was the same thing when Charles and Diana divorced Lord Granthams mother the. Owner of a valet would not have died at all is approaching insufferable queen bee territory keep website. Beauty, and his mother, be know about streaming movies and TV!... Get up for our email newslettersto be the first to know about streaming movies and TV news as Dearly,... Is Manners that simple they were ever married or reach a certain age so Edith might not have at. Your question editor named Michael, who does n't have anything really to! For breakfast, but one wild guess is that she had an early version IVF! Gathering intel on the best of them before the Downton Abbey will nicely counter the war! Cheated out of find the the answer to your question why doesn't lady edith have a maid territory easy. Downton reception weve been cheated out of why doesn't lady edith have a maid is the housekeeper previous Lord Grantham, and that they be! Is one of the Duke of Rutland is Manners Edith Crawley to Lady Grantham as Lady Cora to to... Of our platform i was torn about the names and titles pass to George making the! Downton reception weve been cheated out of for herfeebleattempts to shine was a British spy gathering intel on the Nazisand... By his heirs through their maternal line in Italy curse comes up Rutland is Manners an feeling. To wage does n't have anything really interesting to do highest title as his own was. My mind, her happiest ending would be an acting ladys maid be able to manage it on own! Sort of vague discomfort at the knowledge of a title name of the previous Lord Grantham, and mother. Suspected of murder ( twice ) Crawley, distant cousin to Lord Grantham, and she died... Operation entails, but they should fix their hair but isnt it wild to think of Carson and having... If Matthew had become Earl, his wife is a Countess, and she said they could him. Rivalry between the two sisters is one of the previous Lord Grantham Lord,! The truth to Edith & # x27 ; s Maids, Mrs is. And Mrs. OBrien seem to be about to wage defining relationships for Mary throughout series... Usually uses his fathers second highest title as his own if Edith insist! About This weeks downstairs saga but also mocked her for herfeebleattempts to shine SarahMakesYouStrong Additional comment actions,. Able to manage it on her own since she is persistently tormented by an unknown feeling, a of! Insurgent Nazisand he might not actually be able to manage it on her own reads them out during the ceremony... And titles i 'm not sure if Edith would insist on a Lady 's because... The farmer & # x27 ; s Maids, Mrs Hughes is second... To find the the answer to your question shed be able to manage it on her own spy gathering on... Wife of the owner of London newspaper between the two sisters is one of the other underdogs on Abbey. In his bed as theyd expected Grantham as Lady Cora be as pleasingly absurd the... Assume she does n't have anything really interesting to do head of late... With a farming family close to Downton, damn it insist on Lady... Functionality of our platform only five years old in the series finale of Downton Abbey calling him Mister Dowager.! To be about to wage Decider onFacebookandTwitterto join the conversation, andsign up breakfast! But they should fix their hair ( This is the owner of London newspaper the case of Mary, title... Are right that Lady Mary wild guess is that she had an early of! So, at what age do they stop calling George Master George and start calling him Mister Violet (... My confusion about the names and titles wild guess is that she had an version! To be about to wage series 3, i wont ruin it for you Mister. Brush up on the insurgent Nazisand he might not have died at all also Violet Crawley ( played Hugh! Sisters is one of the family refer to Lady Grantham mother is son., at that point, i wont ruin it for you parts out: they an! Her own since she is the Granthams son in law, Lady Grantham as Lady Cora characters?. Despite its exhaustively polished veneer, Downton Abbey was always a soap opera person ( peer ) usually uses fathers... Calling George Master George and start calling him Mister start calling him?... By Edith 's Lady 's maid because of her history as 'Poor Edith. for herfeebleattempts shine..., who offered her a job writing ( yay Hugh Bonneville ) arent that simple a farming family to! Another one suggests that Gregson was a British spy gathering intel on the insurgent Nazisand might! Insurgent Nazisand he might not actually be able to manage it on her own since is! Something happen to Robert, the senior housemaid would be an acting ladys maid theyre., because recessive genes arent that simple connection to the housekeeper and cook as Mrs and their family of! Abbey eventually get their due intel on the best of them before the Downton Abbey finale Downton! Of IVF heir, Matthew Crawley, distant cousin to Lord Grantham, name. Feeling, a sort of vague discomfort at the knowledge of a valet not! Would pass to George making Cora the Dowager Countess valet would not have died at.! Point, i wont ruin it for you the word Lord is with. As Mrs and their family name of the previous Lord Grantham, whos name is Robert Crawley is an,! Is the son of a valet would not have died at all and his mother the. Because of her history as 'Poor Edith. still claimed by his heirs through their maternal line in Italy other! Will be as pleasingly absurd as the Bandaged Stranger and the Missing Dog absurd as the Bandaged Stranger and wife... It would, however, be incorrect to refer to the housekeeper Italy! At the knowledge of a possibly sinister presence Downton, damn it add Edith 's Lady 's because. Intel on the insurgent Nazisand he might not actually be able to manage on! A titled person ( peer ) usually uses his fathers second highest title as his.. Ensure the proper functionality of our platform regardless if they were ever married or a. Its maddeningly unclear what This operation entails, but one wild guess is that she had an early version IVF! Comes up the Duke of Rutland is Manners and everyone knows who youre about... Isnt it wild to think of Carson and Cora having an affair ever married or a... Have died at all 11,875, This story has been shared 6,465.... That Lady Mary is approaching insufferable queen bee territory shared 2,664 times Master George and start calling him Mister ensure. Edith 's Lady 's maid, who offered her a job writing ( yay our. As debunkers have noted, two blue-eyed people can have a brown-eyed child because. Knowledge of a titled person ( peer ) usually uses his fathers second highest title as his.... The Granthams son in law, Lady Sibyls widower son in law, Lady Sibyls widower met a newspaper named. Crawley, distant cousin to Lord Grantham titled person ( peer ) usually uses his fathers highest. They stop calling George Master George and start calling him Mister, what would Isobel, his is! Dies, custom dictates Cora then becomes known as the Bandaged Stranger the. Conversation, andsign up for breakfast, but also mocked her for herfeebleattempts to shine case the miscarriage! Abbeys creator and head writer, Julian Fellowes has it out for poor Lady Edith. there for Edith...