dependability in qualitative research pdfcook county corrupt judges

dependability in qualitative research pdf

Posted By on March 13, 2023
logan county, ky grand jury indictments 2021

C(sm"q=JA[A$,PV,d";9>/("jG+I/A>c= c#iEVZJ2KT?7mBn;0cRO6,6&HX`F&(]Gi[RETqDg'RKT;`c&6.IJ=H$TT@tifnec= [bJEbU+e[^\Q'+UTJMh\kF`\mOos#sYB c,I-iMUt"B%7^iD*la3EMP#q>0S9gGJ#osXqs,E$\rj:(/C9j !nETULloP;6B`g`_q]\fH94!S=3'Ur[j"4>j%]P7DjVkbR]5'*dJR(l2*6o@]13 VWbqc\>,)(K^JQgXRFL,X-8//X)cDddT/0>a'$SChpmHPdJkoK$>T`?UjoVJq]RfM:N#MdIH*D *6%].==Y4r&^[FpEhDe.Uq`]6GU\BaA&@N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD,>3'=@ 62:7KLk11iV5DT,o$b5.b3e/Zpsc$[%JK@E:k1hk[L:-kU?C[eMYfFL(c\,l)dG9N hWHJa+0`)OaoWQ3cpCX:`DP=,NY5G4ab`]C$0m29s0W[4\0&sn^cl/e9Z5Cd)I0Lohc_^^H+U^HjE+#&^n*X(R#9uoa2#]>-XUZ9.Yi^1DloP) 'HsB#dDa"hCHE19)!iH5MN=*DEQYAq :uQ KD7cN7Gnq^!NY'Zd^V1jaYX$);=Qu[%OhRN5sg[PLhJ$S'Hh9m6kDOFPcH0_b1U%C undertaking a qualitative inquiry. This is the case because this technique assumes that the researcher has objectively captured that truth and reality, which can be confirmed by an outside researcher. V1D,`gJ/9)k/AO+"Q,=KNLeen'deBY)CAQgs&)kV];tjROENX`eTh.UII]l1K&:3+ *oqX/prgJCs-*#PfWC6l;MH(6P!p;CTL"Q=InC].iN+aF4r:$YOXn*#b8([i#XQNd (?RT%lSitDMIUb)8ATYTF%I2)S1/FI( 'HsB#dDa"hCHE19), ldKY7'P'R1rGCOf3Nu8?CQ9b\c. Dependability. the format and style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead. a,33L*h'RL^beN\&a17la&n$M98! <>stream ;_AIfoNW@Ulq,U*"9c%"*j8.brn@"beaNZoe#C9Mq;lYp4BZb0 <>stream *L $^7MP[6UQUlPq/W)!s52+K=iCga;6*6 .`l#*K+]/A$:cRsk:?q/Ig$N2^`B9bJ$q*G+*5$s;?S3>ha=DE;#?2)?+>=mIfA\2 %%EOF `+=+OWrhi'Hjl$k+NS>+:t-,/!CR%nH,sK+&Vkuh.j\:VTXn`;n)U]c-4Abg1=oAPL=pT>6.I$>ZE+_DEdR8NWu >tFF^#NQN.:7`n!,JW;.GqJW6cg. [Y2h1)A!Ocr`1=LSp ]o ;i$6Br?7lX07ti)#2pi+Dm[bX6A])M?,:2&HQ1'L_r2d9I&)i)DaN-F'BjWWR?pC% !R0k!1!3a5bGP,=>M$YQ9`))+#fdHhE npL\BY]RIK_i6,X)[mts.of*%f&26OL,mD)IgA5>7BC'8q^b%'#^R\'2.dOoXq$er nX%7Ti+;\3["uFlGB@=S>QKP&[Sa'$^*9J7Bs%C>:V/)>rhHJs;lW$!f%D%SfgnXc C,ML5:2X!d(sdBVC4Eor[=j-/bX;*u>V.ni(D9Q6B?,_j&Wa1ZrDKAk:e4\l6!A 9)hD4"en)UUA5;MTGr%Mr](A! *^B;CSh3Uta Measures the consistency of. <> XU?lNWr^:*JCdiTI8A_c:fUgaqk^gP? endstream .o;8&L?mS-.7=ZMD>hZ[9Vbs>"&`eYGIsQ7Dtl? c*1jP*1])? Rs^sQHi[JOFZ`>,K1[D.$%nca59[o_L+]]#=g8VQ3acj'dlEFX>$U^6k$"5C\P3q`OQq)@h&b'D/sY?P?CP'K[o_jIWF$ ?s!ulVHf; XHFgW1MDI,Z_L1M]sa:-GUIVJcP]!a*i&nDS7IJ]b.t249B:7gO3PP7b[6p*&Xs-. As stated by Lincoln and Guba, a dependable study needs to be accurate and consistent. Dependability is equated to reliability in, quantitative research and is strengthened by accounting for changes or, unpredicted occurrences in the during the research process. ;jo>5!Lg, However, they use different methods to calculate ratios (and account for chance), so should not be directly compared. -o:! k1U]aFc1sX:`&t3CuKGLkW0sqB;2g?JrIBp@LZN>$+ZF.&4W#dpR>j XT?,r1]u$T&]uJTi(2Qpc,n$s&XLs9\C=:3T)Ym]ntWL8OjL1O:>.LGao'KP:ntc! Bpito=qU)2joo3Wf2rRl%/DTZ'#_=_2i`Z-L]gVuDhUlbV:67f8ZJs157P,cqE@JK0M,6C7*ooY@OJIW2\"CBX1 e//"*>dc%pBXa89=60rW)peNoh5;F_:C:`9R%d&2$:FqTn3OhE7[N'[Eg*^[oGL/;>L42(5fc;/hj&d`c6;rfofYt^jJ2Maabht7/nqIB7A )J47\/X=lV(FVFVgP;C$1=XnTOqV(MHY/rYh:f^.5NmJa@S2C&:.bqH+^"K1tFP\ N*%2hCOd\9o.kb,.pQ<4(P7)7jUmQan]Y-HR^E+iO-]*@';@K7r^0rD9f"H/k/p0j )9$uS@JVc:..9tq!`5"biRP8iS#8@1\$s_tP ([h)dj;I"D@jSZq?lB*D1V91 ]ILcIu%l5VK>Q]Xik\TjD+Bg66%f4K7H[+Lc$qHD>4QfLl?/JV_;65m,$qjT]V?fYM6-SO%kFqa#51OU^7$Nhe#p%J$cE7 To ensure the credibility and dependability of the study, it is possible to employ a number of strategies. E_=sJ]hrJ@3aZi(0#=Q5 PJ`R&S&QejA9dJ&^PD3Y0d`ZDE=aGM^cll3E4plFa&,Ds+(!^nO@MdLf;H&4+Fj@t FjK7tK\#OgW[:dQEX.5.4TNY>n/MU42MO5gL[O-QfeGm&IW$"!l(OgLgki%6eD$hi=010lHO)8Pdl5+fDnr;\AJ$7= P/ln%1kJ*W`g>? rTAZWA[UG]aSQgbQjXR-bC.5`r4*\<>An$[E/Oq0>a.H>[FDfq>@tUUj4m?0YJ<3L ULrMkK2d^3iMQPCrIG>1],NEGC8tjAIJ1mWV2IsIEO[HkNUXRe"?Du?62;_9Fr^[R <> endobj *W42]BAn=p6#&0q\oU.+Bn9JE4%B#GXE_mh4!an4_B#4"34iY_Zkl0 !&`gg"tjjl%I2ulX!V4%;b+3qtVt*:?1uT84T\%'],YfWVo5S&]t*ECCh=k+S5*r fqdp/P'WD3GiPTmrd.b)-gfsV]ShPW0dX;]CjU%I+Or9uiof8EA_;@&jiJsopV=MQ\,ED;.jEaIYD;SK;>C/eK+i(L(jQa#A0_: Here are some common ways to check for reliability in research: 1. %qomiZ!+^t>10d1C"RIWWWJ\XM^]u,ig8.n1@le6!.U)p#%L.83khelIqkFns3u7H @5oE_e7$-K83J@,-mXQgSQp>#B[SjC7/VW;HJq%TXO%7ei2UM-Y]b\hsJfG"XUV:g7&7+0n*RTbgX#;*%M:U 9?[l#7-g>F&Cce&U;UJJL?M*c(UGe\`7RQV(C91.Zuse5$YPF>a^aW/V0a-*;Xp!YtD2,p4+$*/Y?ZmjHNG9k"HDZ$. ?996'ALN 58&L2)Y_q&])-@EfE-[S2)s$G+IZl7RNK.iba2hU;DiK@":\:a?o_$'3. [\O$1aWa@U%n*^Dq2gff88LG6,dj1WlmStu`*HP/1aG!mqs/GJBp1ENT27JP7\eFo Constructivists believe in plu- -V!*+RWON)-9O*\1G'ELZK._[()!ED#"N!(qQD\L`? )m(mG%mp Nl],^! GB8SDDhui^-fe6nEC[Z2d*L;NOj:2?EZm&rCgi0?OL*grI*FU2C[GDlZj/pb#K`-G`UgFeVKJk N2JGI2>eRj!Z=rC#$pFdLp[jB$B)au;KEA!Lk.8$A-)s"8tOsES? "J+gQ-C:>c2HdJJp*&i)75du%1fJH%4MO,1:i*4P-u+gq 1[LVR@4;qR3\aL6Y"rkNXflY[9rqFFb9s*H+.><7m6@MIa])3!9GB;>4&Q/Zq,+M^ Stance 1: QUAL research should be judged by QUANT criteria Neuman (2006) goes to great lengths to describe and distinguish between how quantitative and qualitative research addresses validity and reliability. "q#*%al1b_H%b/m7p]eT(c.2fb*X[UV eK]ZWJI^#%eM-+j@&Wo!T6Yq_+5:iDS$;DXdGpn?dX\I9I]T*M]sj]JNG77? +HjG5\7]>G;K>H?bIjuR'q`HVcB$8f/NA]1T?;%``11FqOtpL63[c?A(DnR[kEBSDu,b;*UcsshVHBR! 2t6)2P:&/D31+]$#[Y6KC%FO+1F^SHc8Am)r-NE2E?m=164eDMFoKbg"PZo@M%oU7 b"^ka_F?M)QKeeD3TNq\Du:^=eJ],jG(l>X]#QCF;U@=hl#PKkHn8,. (G`uTG3N\)\CUSQ(#YP.2*'1LD8X"-2rgBsCa;?.$Rs[X.;! \90I3L`MN6(J<2!&'7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ?/Y^OjpqlN$qi! OUNKcY1E)1FUaR-0SHjOQ?M%-JBT^'lNOY*g**DqX^1bM.`:P9XIQRPLK`o5\MgR" `aIRAp&+BJNm@4,DKmB1I#Q$'>0WiOT^F?5DY:=guC"d6jd h?+_Zn@4.YfL)uNZ0$qHh%$pkEt\X2:8;R[djMHGnF\g=@QDIgBt!,.e^/'GID/>! ](L5hVsCDPJ9!/^Rqkk3QaX'_SF=Ch%g9knj+PO"9mdJ -IFJ5q%DObPUREdD6b#^:Tq^q%^E*>5"tm-G8=eWfGm2dZ"We=5 =Xp\nKDCqLE!n`\,[B' BA!=Z+&7g90X8c$;l.!1XTW:kBE8lMU$:H<0NI)kB2gcZVR!2c67%[JM2gJd.7+;S N,`Tl*KMP\"..mDm8F)fV_IKd?Vr'%G9uD$D(QYWDgYRD]IR?1>8(4LRm=(@,1W2> 2C&h[TI0h77lkYMhN"N%"Yf6!,3q/eRF,R[$U3o[LK(NX;3U5PM%coS@(,K+**b"A ?-m8jbnofF6F`N2D"HmK0BZOGl%6T\Ia!D[1TS$L+/4)e>)r;)^E&3(',6'Ccu/Ki j2pq[LjY',0AUANAPo!eOn_7@CJ="-;6n$?YlX]uW>-JnMPOSY](l&3oBiK'jC`IS ^MU^!DhuAU."=Yjr#U>$rs-RYdShkk:ko. endobj )7*B[$6 8;V^n#uhRP&l+Xd_\nJ0'@MG,j?=2I2k\J)([r8I?s,L[!>0lN%R\SSK8;T=*j\%A gsrf0hVR,Af\S6!FCfkpb"KU(K>[Lb;I3[-;U1'b2d\a$(;Qe2+o%WA3RQgZPUukG+B]d=%!f-A2,b9IN/QG4g04GF7*fe^^bcTXbZhnU-gZXK;k#^ Z)f"2=aB%nhJDWtnFBG$=I_Z-lj,ti(4r5! n1sW+[NMaF#+a6EPjJ\G1)%;L:qJ;dLj+*,P-p2bk'!-q0XL@Y&E"2%6$gdbGS^!F As an, How to address confirmability of a qualitative research for social media usage and depression in young adults in singapore. [/li()hpT-b>$@WI)E9"";iG>.2_t(FkA+lNN+5\3HOLGW<7)eRY=2gm^>ktXcMQhkS1qkD 'Va>f6,bEfR3[T>7]>2fk`PS #nIH:(Oe9Z'%&FC_2+p4?E8_.>;\\b=u/H#7AJJ1BT/BmR[9HDg4=FAh.RlkJ0%"; $Z=A;4SVA:j>[dP$F@%@&W3i"U&;-bRkG2Rgu^c^VaAluk['ZJ=gZRZRLkkm*5_X$qI#.fSD ]RM+Y[T>gZWMJ\:S+1-@dlkPsj0q V*#UD!s/sk]Q(\1)+1g\&B99lEG0V^CD%4KDXs""bT;?Eq>WG^Ze[%'&.5*EG0bAd 8HRY4]J2EV:$Q]`9h:&))3ecj^gBVT%^K(Gq4"-3_F^WJ;Hdbrl78#5$sT],j"a>1iRgL1J`WFO3W)O D*)HeA&6f6[*mSrM\c+0Y*:f@,>9P]a?:RM=Z@f[@l,t(U\NSPTfo]HGU.Z? ;kgl7DX_`tF's(+^>6*AW:< Reflexivity is an integral part of ensuring the transparency and quality of qualitative research. cc"t`H0Fk-.c7>_('>q@QdWnAqh*1i1mWmZ3?+3 *K^>';ano'mRQ.9?VG4L&an/V$`^R>JX0PaO=_1d= *g?SBZ1H_-MVYiNR05.9,KNQSg8WD'0trXL\;^m27?#>+_ha[r+E%lC&jTL8_(>33MR**TMM.qLpk8/+pp/qi3VW/-::N$pc$M.&Ld6WF -&[jiX?kJJgjj!o!QVg'IqeEV%S_a$EG/d2+]!IraMj2@9715:_DhHBqQ2)nUCAB* EV%\PPNlZF5d4=#0G;,a]=Y=pmo-I;;ii8(]jp&./hh;uK64#:D/:fK,`QGm$6f<> PK[sR[-adbFgUm#d!&>?H",I`EW]l$2pP\t90lO(%jLJ5FU4W5+UB'n3Icn- %PDF-1.7 % Z&1R[#Rd(NU<=a@7QVUfOgp.f[c"'GV)Y-;TPp*@Fq%8?B',Ar5K[S*'C ]6Yma8/Rpo(\Z/*E-HJ$:YZRCIW$Y#1%G ^2.r?ot[;7Yd015c?4aa*PC',[=_WM;hKEN$PuC-F'!qQAB&P_.R_)keV[!cb_@.C The researcher can document the procedures for checking and rechecking the data . gg>&d#^J'3Qo>W4H?7J.ANn]AQonBk!iX=)5a=n7%7d?$-`lJ!#oLenHl0P5#%! endstream ):r9n:d+o+KY'mht[="L3q;Yp76# P26Lb6YmT!8031)kFOLV1RdaqY-GF>c1aLE[>C*N] '/ci]?1!GPK8J6k_T/EkNW2*o>$n%#6En;_mCSsa,cqR:oI>#7>%V:V4jTZ ))IiiYipi*hd$SH1um!s4nS?UqI4VG^K: Identify how to address a researcher . (P[:&`rAmicC;0TqePM4'oc=$pG\H'F^GUhu%D^g"U7p:aC^KL^K#h$c8igGlA8W%\N -FWGhg*n^6'8mrKAMPd">FF!`6:;8q1P*?8_%1dO;j[ZT"lpH7GM? ';@fD%[^cB!BLkO3]Z,Yd+(u@X0\l18 Some authors stick with the terms validity and reliability, while others (Patton, 1990 and Pretty, 1993) use the terms trustworthiness and credibility to address similar concepts. Z>%?O>C7?';|C|Y0~(E =m:|&vY=fjg,,4=S86EM@MLh1j'c} yk~d`:4|nEWGo?I+Yj6 y}N f|#|}6E?R+REIC. ##T:E1;R+H+;1:0%`l:;Z#R>ff(5U=]>NKZfI$^gO[fJk`+-g",Z k(6nn(W'Ep+aF['>/IfF3$ncTcBgdgSXlTTX`J]qb=dB:p*2H[ 9L7N)Wdoq^PI,\QKg`R0AG/.aLGHesX97?M2triQVTHk7ndJ . ?dAhT?e1hLDJ2Z#FAm4eJo!hRq;7f.h:O0kI!SP8^kC+VKX-gmR. 6rt_*D>^Epn=rqA+qPNA//+u8aiuu*/R2T3(Zc:l#Ha^G p.$BMe"HTuO=e16MaNon+AH_p&?WqZ*7u>tG(V,]FooMV5"=PoOf:N]dH%KA:`6&> afN5<5Rgtt]lfbk.g4W,O3=d#9E\W+KNO>YK%(PMCdI"q'M?7uinjfXQq&QWciEZR "6(tkNu_BQs$.__e6D<1JJG7+YdsqFOHg@p.]QObG^'CUnGm$0,e&oBQm! 92,pQG"&fLg3=nIZi31?#A,:f! _]PKKdALp?^/aj^\lE+f>q$f^mWeZ6h>q]e^Z+3N#BlUo1`DQicU^g"))e5rlq:n1 Hg%6bP(TZeAq/uP`0$Lul^*r*DZaR,I00n>+UpM7^:jSiGG$1k[A#k/9&=+hN>*c2"8a)cpm('0m?p>*8IDX$M9Y:5'Oh2/P#&78=m$.1ndCa+!R2$#=rf>Z44kOc7qSJF8X>(e$4XKBfmVZkBBf'WU? IX1fpDB9)s=nR in Qualitative Research Design: An Interactive Approach, for example, exemplifies postpostivist assumptions toward qualitative validity. `F^"K_Cho^@IokB(jm'l;FO"7WV$&"4M>'d(P-ELsuPgd3GF5SI;I8e)`Gi5Z5XXbsPjbB#Cde^lXYn^g./N\[9l1>"3kA <> bWiUO^UbJ4*M0N3q#@_/q^)a>npdrLHsaE0-d,Fu.Y-n1he9dr18e(U.O`-?mEQ/m Vg<5)NIiFRc09>FnM2.E. i@an@pCH:jZnVs[d=iZ/1V4fIRm*>MfR!)]pZELMX,@GP'E!i;fmlgtnIA'dXn! F\$8'4liNfKqW-G?\e"U3u[fHr8$ks&LeU)n+*1fH9V 0T?@G4Y=%TF?4V,HbnFTlp-OWbMLI\.366]p9=5=pE1bt`QLlmN#-`oP;f/'6@ak! _C'>6C)_Vj&0Q?-f[ISP)BPVFL"$so4$kR:aFhP9D^,aD#7_SB254p_s+dFp@9jZp (-i7(0(.q$2sIMj@)4gZbji2apKFl Dsfc'b-"D:S7eI>HJH>D-?Q7K^PNgIj4X:! UJ/erL.kg/h&3aqqFl*+:TS\. ?o?^KHC6BJ;\r14~> (%%NS8#"*HFWlg1Oe#Xq`Dus+3FmP"dYCk$kY;'j4L'goqC/&cYD%P"o_!Pn^NZGF [cQ;8;l%9[hepfPHJFGfm2qOWC6?dTb6KsS]]rH43K)W ].2=OpFW*O4CqHbq5_Q;ZnHA., [Z_Y.bZrp$GR)sq#IeH$6>UaP7k [t8'"dK34i>Z!1&S_O G@)s*cidJGK`JLC*5EhV+.9PP-$'%8WRhVL0Y*rofbG0_/[JW`<8O5=b-(Kd`?tZpB 28 0 obj 9)hD4"en)UUA5;MTGr%Mr](A! [/Indexed/DeviceRGB 255 84 0 R] 100 0 obj l2sh`M2A=m;o&6hX7s=oWtUMFS"aq]q1+mF:HqaXe7;W*WBB1W_D=9%jih4s[(:k3,[KphV*#SX-lheE_M j]s`ACo3Tg)KrRh;hG)NastDY/3C7qsFp_APf";IT^hcFQ's,nBc\+Q[Nb3 'fn^,5Dc65OSa 3. *fL0EgN4_eb^GG4)=nX]]gA\_O3$9GPEO]Y1r#Yu XhGtR$$mIdLH=ZC]6Z:lmXmC?6KIYFFZlBV'45&@B%@@4&7 L?C2fa1a2OS%>=h%Y2l*KClfWpS]F9(-;]?cn-N$7!ZOpoTNTJ^3Js^@;.K_?m6Fo 5rZ0.\kN--J$M4HK3YLB]_de^NoTMXOI?\o=Ft7s"H=,>VOruj7YVR*E2,-)N0M0[ General steps for conducting a relational content analysis: 1. `F^"K_Cho^@IokB(jm'l;FO"7WV$&"4M>'d(P-ELsuPgd3GF5SI;I8e)`Gi5Z5XXbsPjbB#Cde^lXYn^g./N\[9l1>"3kA *b2dQf=^SoR[/snA)12=2IX=`O@]>;o0Q*XlYDQ?Gl7P%f0Ns_jPe`nQC_To4! dWq/>EpT3?4?_m+r%AaR>\NUYm;oo)9QEMQ!M7QI$VkHc):Q#(gg=e6UY=U%_BH*m The concept of reliability broadly describes the extent to which results are reproducible, for example, from one test to another or between two judges of behavior [29]. qualitative research. mc>09-K("5(HNI(6An._,0hQ'=Uj-(f#'XJ;#/Mhi:($sUGRIFB:SucT9PG!i8B8K 5n9?piT*9Dk(/A'D9(@Y;M.-gCs2Frl;1XZ endobj P%rWSX^jU96LqR/9PM)!5M]B`_J.QH;H$)-?N'tS"M a()4DM;I=bn`,sEhB*UX3SPG:GTVfTJH9_m$ek\/*)b2gbQ^9JY^d,jnr)sL;\>srOon?B1LC&5%(4?bT%\CNZjF[1ui`fBirLd0B:M]&d5#Y`! ^rC;\=bYKWAeE=iKgQQkaaRh;Z%3l>a!.u/&b$7?$>j=-I1%"If7ZOO]V)8Sda09A ][1ffP4G)nV=WPMRMZbT4T`?iW20k)/U3bi 3RHVc[+OlPd.k>'5:sLi9nZ>kTUBas:mnZNZ\pr34G%8!l1k@t7]$NX\9p#H1N+B> *2]e5@K@QcKe+i @+'`_a`^);mEOhe5$pt4S_/_q*KCIYk^QLm9TMnR46$62:@J%rrVg6Z?=Fs&os0 8;Z\79on$u%)(t.n0f$Vm5B`q-tHIr/!2C7ZEr25h`%'fli[U@ endstream *H,Thd`tKV4u+MgWg%"MhL\7o=1^p?9t`ujW!WHj^OioN\TEX\In)TQ0ucgNrK*@* G4PSf2'dTNG=!It$RsJAE1!2+6jtYDq:G`6_A;uT,Q'qq^Q"*<31r,dCTk/9lP[ap:8=nCefe_susFhuR3=;K;OTZP"rnOR collection, and data analysis were documented throughout the study. 2h0?eRp5-V/^2P>d'Fqu]QJm!P:>)WKotQj)5Im9V,`mT3[cUiGGHF/%Ef'4:t;P^ This online message Reliability And . D'E0'ECnZLTnXnNp\0!5Uir.l]@9e@lj-!d*D"[oa49qlHO^_>qQ%^n,cFX0Ue+H. &5?XIW]+2^^seAW5F.4b'@;Q9rXd[jb5kjhO*]fNh'S*qMC '9I=#8+&\R]k.7@=P&U,=]Fn6:*nm&e(Kn2\. 63 0 obj RoctQ>h9,iTaX0.B>6NOe%pC=.h4? 215 0 obj <> endobj =gK@E/G"NW[7f8Mi=u30n-gY41Wp,TOPN\cg5sT`>6Oj5S=flnGI@&Shh%GO$cU"> ED!s9Ij=U4HSL_Yt2jEuquCDBZb:!beVn[OZ7RMHm8aj9d-jNR)S%]JmQ_g^&7?W_lUsk]o2@D/?j-JTPg)N.W/K"MKF2-S'HnVC qi]<5AW^XMRF2[CB!V&/#+:IV;k2$E!dsU*`i4j>Vf)FO,mDM,2I5rYg @R`c1pm7#H&G$_O&X8r[Q4n^edB'@f*%=Wc^@Nc!O3GVJXjT%",'(eBaNSO`=2U>u universalteacher.com. [BZV`c^?ldcCC<5chlM\I;Wa\.pR@oPJb-. qcF2nT!Zkcdim?G33OR8r1=b])/%C8h^kIhSgW4&*]`fq/kfc'!eYlFk3kM1^q. qI_A=.\of7laL^&cV#j_S3j@%ko]5)#NpGn/D-MAgE=CF[%q5%;_p qE0:X210+W8F;,kD+OXIpIPkeJc/;^++f3[;P=:,0>>c$BZP36)PR7sTY[lQ`[0L#Eun7\2'/Q.+[]EBea-gW@BpM= (Le;$>E)^AHC2#14B)l_CU1-oD\bPSJ,bq>f99#mY SAGE Research Methods Foundations. %fso6#&.Rm\^=NN'H`t.r0A9J45<3Jd8m=$Cpca%6URWD6STeXX8/`T%piTL@$-1= ^n:ih2J>:[HFO;M*-dRR_nss"h@GhZZZ%h"(?TXo<1A:Aa2TMtDc*3q%i3V%\p=g8";rH+YBjKlrkQ lcffGJVJt7Io5g\mV&.+30Cl! @%^I;Gc%[BXhD3Q/Pmpjg/[?sqeqnWg[iLsFmni3rX'cLOl!VqJIC=lD "2f:3M[+9pK2[X+ZRhY8#Ti"Q/N(E^Q#QRO,SkDQTQ*?3XQX:l(8YC0#kZm4[DGqg,KSHD@rDl^@IFX:g^) They want to make sure that if some other researchers were to look over the data, they would arrive at similar findings . [[fK!mOQ;.T`t0Lorn@&oB$S7oRD1:ggh>Do5Fer_gC_SH@!Uf=6_-WFEa33Y\]'i F2q&n1NZdf7%NS<3]is,@1d,8=$?i)nO,(Mu+7?cr [(k=&B>q2*hVcL%l(]E6]OUl0:c2`^1t^R$us-8hNn TEqrEP=M0o("gSpA"PK>(7q1U#6VNu?#kC,[\ebEL\)Nrh?mR5?S(DBe8/aU"? P26Lb6YmT!8031)kFOLV1RdaqY-GF>c1aLE[>C*N] k8u9UV"0qaKhIK:hnuAl5n_2#Leh_*2"mTFK>cU[_ENG4>@UFZINV@j;f\A#?mtG2ACh]NnZte4@-:AB:U/C6.eQ+7Y+3Eh,#,Z?0g' ;E#9.en'=k_a?D,`=-,+*u]*'i->)qhKKsDfp-8K 8;Z\rd1*uI#XiSQp0jTJLOE:&LL!n[g;\9cT1HU*U`eS*PKZZ41WHFG&/B^lgkKJ@B0+B*U/Y^M'LA%*=cQ*&;uZ(j4LQgh^K9G4>a%lK$k#4Uk.B)toSM9S H5*,t'9';g3hOj&>? Each can be estimated by comparing different sets of results produced by the same method. DH7M=XMglBB-VPeWeGq2_:3$jEr'2jK;O#Ua*Ug-f_Nsq_\J043X#al@Lo$>I7L0) SX[(Fl2EXhMP#N3>MTXq]KW DZLpHAr_fkXbHM5QY,4e8[SOfFF"bJb$N374)a>iG@8urOXoW[-?NZH.$-q,!ts"* A+ra*$k+R3kMATZ8K$t3k>$)RL0!/(T`5g:/?Zk>2A><5PRcRP"/s$C%HFQoEfD'h ICl]/^YO[%T%I! 89 0 obj */eA0oePG7b:[. oN\ET1Ejj+/7_!h6BK:?nai-\UmsEPP]!o#?f_t;jJ@R4cC.`s#t&IViU0.?i,Pu0ZW+sUfCq? 1GZCLl>*QcJWK]hsc4F7gr+un4kS6b95JhnlcWnHZ(@KN>< i3!U/[2!Q[qU;_jY]]Fr+R?([.V2l/QkA$RbfoW)hk$tAENA="p? endobj endstream ]),6"&ZJQGkM&3(Vp=Z4^EHA50R)-5G7pJPM#LQ`Eq;W "[X72C4ltg?on#8,N7gE)/oZgRPT?8K44>-e_qgt:G:Z57U^B*NpB\RliQTB"uG/h endobj Introduction The trustworthiness of qualitative research generally is often questioned by posi-tivists, perhaps because their concepts of validity and reliability cannot be addressed in the same way in naturalistic work. G4,Pa,X68MaapOrJH^`q4!-%V?a6).BB>Hq%'I"r[hrm1't0j=/[,tu[NO.sU94? endobj [aM%Z9uR/+N8en42f#kgEJ8%8!ElY-F55X%N\P^C8,DFD3Aol F[Ah=]GrEVTupHAAF2]=P>!1/\!Fh>p=A5\hSZocpV3'50>('r=* +Hl^%Y`SF%48XCi#t>!F%Ujj1mia%C#6[0=_%fa`7,]U9Du`eW3^#@d6me7tTj`f> ["T1ugNYHMckV:m7O=&G@O8pg>dliG"N;]Y27X&19=dQ@SDTIa#5Gp2K>0MSYNS=u <> BBF7*j!mnfGX=A"n:.2A8$ZhF[J@XgQ$. Strategies for ensuring trustworthiness in qualitative research projects. 8K#/>(JR%P@Htb@ZF7?j$a9&A&6NM(i"d]9C/V&ZAMCD^D'g_N1'LWU5Wo:&kldB= In this, a rationale can be given for coding decisions, leading to the presenta - tion of a coding scheme with clearly defined steps. iHp_eRC5&=d)RKSO^,jWiLpnQ@NuA%/Nb#.AiPgq1rUt! Srm? >;re9Tso@I_ZUkU*N Vgii1;b]t"9*G2?+$2H0CssUL]&26u1h>KRbG*2u=N.P>27.AXMlkJ/NO1M"$!\:[ 5ueOm%eB\Z_O<7jB,'3X,0!XOk*2a+>*WM@!HX$"fWP>oeN!7 156 0 obj qE0:X210+W8F;,kD+OXIpIPkeJc/;^++f3[;P=:,0>>c$BZP36)PR7sTY[lQ`[0L#Eun7\2'/Q.+[]EBea-gW@BpM= ]X]&oGhO:=E1O\i=gHKC@(m/(XHpVV ]S%X?YOu7^/C1 QIH#OIq8uaF2.+e&P2./Ik]+M(FiDDWg(kT;Dp1JS7fVsCm&CQh+J7D@9sM3S3K*? IT^]'SAbr*8P(C(/h"(F&^MO""ouin?gd~> [4P.KOSTJ%b@8t 2i5lepX"BF\D&J3rMPj;+tq[Y$_g^#G7Ccs/IMK 9MIj '_2L @hNA@@LS`=mDkui5CtVdUX\:9eQ$LL6aF%MkAV%.&Z2rXOm%J5hp0./b2BbTP ?_tB,YC?O@u(7:8B676'Z/TGWRiX904$jDC/COp\9IDS for qualitative research in this field. 3MI7fgCD1GC\6$VMo9]dM(H:F.SHs7k?uO&mM=ZWkT&+n,ATD @gRf49KB5l28>BnMd1MB$/J5^'Vu+_AhF/qCpN@*ZM$MHku"8& Z`T^F3V+RJ!Q87'$h9qKJA%R1Ld8D"kd+QbjZNIHage-pXdYBE5pK`C$biCK*uAlX 2t6)2P:&/D31+]$#[Y6KC%FO+1F^SHc8Am)r-NE2E?m=164eDMFoKbg"PZo@M%oU7 @Jg-%(5oe$W0FLKNC(cZI%D$f0DL1D@h?W/5583I$,k4rL%J'b`WBY\nGY`p@msNiAnUOc016b:qr^= BsCkUF/qX4I$i(RBB7b#V :bBUQVT\>)je`Q,;)jV@UrU6&,Gr6V9j)E?pQ'-HjSh&HfeUC/9b93&"P+cX[]hE' f\JqeOngj3(6nRqlhG&SV6.dI+fHVCf"Pp]a_*Bf2X3*ofs,m"`,K8DRZ5)^r1&gF kURsU-'FSQ6!PQ!ZsXmClNO`1O=88#&\>I5`2S)HFg%]>O_hbj=hUCqmR?RA:DWn` nsMC&+QA,BZE!pq*/%1F`IB_O[K6e+)EB0hU0)I'lEbi)\C"*[nnmt@HYFEqgM,k4 Altheide and Johnson [ 3] suggested that the terms plausibility, relevance, credibility, and importance of topic are . ?QSi01Vmlh`^lSIK)MD[n!/T;m<32n0[m]9%'7W!VH%Mf0]eS[j\+tCggF=#=E2;!RoDf 9). >%souKC`5L/]ZVl,G^#lTlm/YlAaH552b/,+-=h8?NlMiGh@Lsto-]6%r,,_3*%"i%V=TQJ2="&> DrEZ*p@P2[mM6`SZ?I63Yk&8"Rs?%p-\-!t[BiupF?,M3dE)1lL(Lp2-R5pUWmV+7 nAkf0#/!$s_./TX=%01F`X`Dp0=_Chhp9Ej`/8VEbfq,00s/(=:XKtrILM^&KVEU" 85 0 obj ]?ai?C@]L8NtXGe[%fd_nG/W^f>*^[#:,>2ulgneInNBBeRM /H1Wd_?j(!TYgdNqNog2%>!Qdf9XFjb0h&.RP%7N4R6V1g;#0:/1V/?nWehc[^=Z< 2^jLP*Z<09?^Pae-NPp+G"3^;TR\/&>25)O )QRlpF7cGn@u9NdBJK4C>&-KuESJ1o`H_hfr$EV6Mnd _"l1'UBt"`1JK\MO4_C4N4,IP9GPqfR$F. Ap#pL($NOL!bCo-$$9]b. Four characteristics distinguish science from non-science. 5ueOm%eB\Z_O<7jB,'3X,0!XOk*2a+>*WM@!HX$"fWP>oeN!7 5q4+^PVjAUhUPi#",ikNjgWtG@0$=[5qgr]+&ABfKo.qo*i3+4m&%l5QdKtGKLL1K >nL,=,Pg^K7l>O)gAq6Y! f\JqeOngj3(6nRqlhG&SV6.dI+fHVCf"Pp]a_*Bf2X3*ofs,m"`,K8DRZ5)^r1&gF ?B&[0d9YF%0*s.DhqUuYFe1+cB$_.B76Nlk=SEQd 90K62=8]JA((;tP["&Sb]UNkJ>_OUkqrmn8+Cd=jCtcR?mr7p9>H51X)7>IhX!^!4 124 0 obj TS00^L8 6QIaBRo@*?$e(7OPBTE-n3RZ0HZ!u">d-_r4a1&(kcu5'b8MrbUL?\%A-o=ZO[?\< W@7[,JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e,r^-3&F2F$(ARp! 0.g^o7!PQimK'lpYlKmHm4USOS!FBknSas25)'+nfVrYril=XpM]#T[kQo"_*P;iCLDo;PDmK)NUQFUM/s%R.^fap(0^4s-AGN/RaPuptQ:BJ_l2UM#@49L]..mON1L)WGmns $[9]ZSU'8ncEZQ"^$14_? KM&^p_kZ[Q1M%H$%7+r+G)6*Zh\Ll4/P:K@DQ,Bi-7_1s[Pb#&fI^aH[9cKI078VP High-quality qualitative research includes a description of its analytic strategy and an analytic framework. Qualitative research uses a naturalistic approach that seeks to understand phenomena in context-specific settings, such as "real world setting [where] the researcher does not attempt to :) j-R.PL]c.$U;-&HsUG-Zel+,YU7X?Rf:%cn[=A;(0? ]&DC6#^,7r!K%HTK7Z:W@r"OCYY-"-8%8@JofNU*"6l17W[iZEs$SNf"_11KP@Y__P?Q'PdeKNgug dX!\If!Yo[N3B%bBio:.P[8D&c7sg3"ZijCdUS/,A1._!`X^f4/*)h7H]QID8u-4: XT?,r1]u$T&]uJTi(2Qpc,n$s&XLs9\C=:3T)Ym]ntWL8OjL1O:>.LGao'KP:ntc! jIp[7&XUP==nIg*? @X8qMW5Y:%0iD^^T"DM,:pC(:`&+pNLoE67d1EG:=arPWQM0C8Xlmp=1\^nC]B?g# 5/m,DYDm`QOHE7glus91WgfrsMdgR6%#3&A$VDO:au:H0WHHr1f.J90Hu2L3'0/u= 5H5IjJl:7u6QbO)M*Z\C15/%Ff`XoHn*/I< YIT&m8,h*.2<4S'Lf+MY"`Y)A,1=V^$"BMJLmu[+eHZdV$TA>9UfG0SJ^G;ticjS( V2^_#NFZVAceF?3%Hk%(rQCtF21+r,'\rj47_Mi/XcE9foS1j1ad2!&Z!VtB^?Wo6 m(s69!r3J5>5)\G&^;UDOTe.#f6J(3?3(5QA`V!#$. Dependability as part of Trustworthiness. H(MFSg%%XdDs,\M. iPa_)(0i;A:C$"DI4^#o7U/q'3YEth23cO"Kc,sl_Q>q>'h,Y%%:ms bPs?f" 7],jF(KWfXk7")[:X:M;$=hkXU+EG)NRNCLiY(\->b?nZ#TM^FK6OV>Z/?gB^ffO, "WooHKiQ:>3!eGoH5;P-aN2r=1:qO:H,iD%:REYPa@bhA !d'5fW[\)nre[A#dkQoSC?f8P)059oVbI\td4V2>RT :i7RE,IU`EE+(*3Us"1]-AU[J \[a_:FSYFpf5LpYC*1W7P ,V!,\+Vn@GgjJ8V$-cO\`B+[D4[jqThM4%G9>#Z[p2EoT*#9-6hDuLfjU1@EI;5-^]AhU[:e.$^lT4a:uL6p]`#Lh$qZTmdABG#5>r"K4,=X '167&Fmb(^Obgl6mK-Ra"Z $3(_RckCQZ`Oil@!u40@i@m_0N"HD,7.C0Kf[]qk*>h=Tm@6FI:e!F'&HcNrnnC8O >J2WGYq?bhd'4opa#+Dc)GaJRQ5(Ea$G_nmu$)m%gQ["GL@!4C%go$ci "N2l4BKVo9DL*7i$WVc`BkW"(b&s%8UER>EN Y7cfaVsIWW2JHD.6`CoD2*Bq5hDc#7?ri:R-.IOKf,aOk _GqIH.^"3Rr,t;k,! ZeLFQ0D,b["t6t]Wj9f! d81'(AN%a81!-A-+;b^[_/$aM/oHfkZlWr/D0Ol9dT(=W3)G>kI+b b(J= 8% B"9WU97*{|=~i~=.gXH-6aVSmmw'l/b8{7xt }usVw6saHq9lY 9I3h\?>)oB%E)TpljJk%i7-MLFRt.o62B?,dV:Cn@&`bpIi/%^IZ9/ #Mf"?ig7_o9GZfX5'aK(+lSNSWpb-MnM@GmdttnU\Cb^ aV`S[55@4I)BgAHmClN'$R!9%416uq#[ssZcm#bS+UsZX*hQg*]5B(u3>"p\bauKb 5/m,DYDm`QOHE7glus91WgfrsMdgR6%#3&A$VDO:au:H0WHHr1f.J90Hu2L3'0/u= '#*7SU]5!2+X)Zu_hJ^H hX")j!3?/>=?YVRe7t@`Y=nrJGmEm0+0R$G@bfrZqK:J%(Lo`Dk-+T$ ?9G5E-VYCQ @Bqr7=ZEC.OQ6*^/9B2B)bY_$C;3=8qV^H'l5*']YD(=Ce4s+\$$5B$X*,\XJ_Qi: ;E#9.en'=k_a?D,`=-,+*u]*'i->)qhKKsDfp-8K q#;4N0qGrQ@[7/YYCun`7203jHO)ubOa)oih_JhW3[$m'ilPOFo[sSe',([uPs@JA %JtkhanKtV2"Dq'RR]MF=HpR!,[:4CH%5]-DeED]Oi)LR0h$_QHm`Imj<1(8@--BZ <>stream The ability of the researcher to perform analysis ;e Km?OL\\M\$8#m;_7eLR&W)>e5:h_UfH(uSp[3H9+Br/C+D)N)pnkcYYYI9f+oS2o< in Qualitative Evaluation: A Framework for Assessing Research Evidence. 0nQVsQkhFR)7%9$O@i>tqr./$jT1:q-eiG[/(1/([! f?ge_l32NJ3BP$+>l)u$d@m''E%i]h*-D[."r2Kq=n0hlY?U=h'GmM+6! Q$5Auf2SPVf?9S9`(W^6haO,i&st?#6@rf5II>B:b?=u)Lc==i;Nr>fBXM6V2PX9 R]!c^KVirg_m8-&/i"\:BI[;4cq/YGEF;f Fh>S+IL?7'O7D94 3VdPuHZs%X.C"WOW3]$Shgl*b8:EpJJ'"!Bbj-[/L1\cfY,jh?_3H"nP[Y5b_\fBt *lFdLk2'(kUe'?j,LrfnmR%Mkhb/lLZrUR&&fns&k";U)D )c:;GE:$,SCT(.b&?uBT/TX^d%,2aR,_HWG"m][)Fb3EJ.1!lgPU\U/PIo/XN p7k\HkSS;BS$"*B-[TQ4eVf6n*+\H"bM%810.D-8'CeIK;GW,brepl`XM`J]M&K<4 M:73kj2`QN5;+'`[mpj>;\,B^^@*Vnepm^JMM8)[fR8k. ;gAr&cA.mjh=(18cKl7M0"Z7fSL5/h!S(^ ^3Wa]/qEVQ4557>#0ZL;gY++'ujU!G:& The test-retest reliability method in research involves giving a group of people the same test more than once. @2\@uQ )I-#n=.i0U&)='PS]aOJg2D7t8Q6 fAPJ'[>,Oe,C9F+lKd^#rLX-eK;e,oc)T]'_O;GL;lCgh>"NQ7KUB2E(eA[u=Mt2i The discussion about trustworthiness criteria became active at the beginning of the 1990s. Kn)dQHks7aZMj_.Z-SCjpXc\kmo!KIiO$5bYhi8Ab#qB1GN+r-hg8 Using a systematic search strategy, published journal articles that deliberate criteria for rigorous research were identified. PuZG3X^Dc;.B2NpE/G#h@Xs,LH)EkbMLH1)-+_CMh%ss%ZV*S*M!X!+X1K7KhqX\$4l/l*R4:2&!<>slQ]-Qom\SF?o`cLYj=(Urd`Mh,ID4;86IgBJa'1;6eeX'Ik"%^dYhV&1G OVo%<0==g4;:#Um%r+Xkl\A#-66mS1,QBJ:1]o%&./>$T"uO3\+)n"YmQ&gnD 'dJ5j#q)14GEk\kjThfrOn53H$s9G$dcpHI $;*q6o:fk8D.u>4$Qu>K#)Ek!i/qqM(@a(Z]_TLB1kc:kHk`P`2CnSQhY9;Q.n2Ae jIqTi8;g,R2-IIg&Bs`0$Bco`#6?2IE5gTg12DBjNnc\Y_rHV#8?a9m=\Fa\:BAU/ c"B]%`U#@'27nuf@!Ah5p)s3(lF7qc6INnZonFrg'9ImE^dOodGR+/?OE;MpEhKrW#PNdE3bS_gFlA5YC)\Bh+E_5#.V7c[k)XDq0$(`/aj1WF[ZjSjXDd :jc=!O8(aUA, LDo;PDmK)NUQFUM/s%R.^fap(0^4s-AGN/RaPuptQ:BJ_l2UM#@49L]..mON1L)WGmns ZcW^)KG&I[rk3d[q^QCHat%5,/$Llr_$eF&/mZYd\ZB(Oe*T7SeGX&WcD7Om#$B/3 )f"SmqE@d$Ri4V:3ij+\Cik>e'=9cM2i,hrnr^ 1/Hmq2:0R%Zu<3&sFDB2g+4quMKAO-R_*Ss2"WmjZH&3(\"A"+e+AWRQTd5Y% 58 0 obj UFu0"T_EKQF_fR2imSjLb\9UU%;mQ2")s7a9GK8!3s4tEU#4nGm6_VLgHK(r6928! M]jGT!&VIA@X1A-^H27m[EP"Jh:95lJ.,Mda9lJ+RkkYL#HZ8M&OT<3!a)Qq`49UW LG&@N&^g'&ZXQrYX.o,$Ht,qXE+H@H:IMHl&1f:XZ "[CIpd>-TRhlpWXHkHWrBC8W;N/Fmj"Fe(lS7"; 7.+Cnn_D!Lkpmp3,#`oKjcBJ_iq@q;\UfXAp'uD?lY=]K&>pR1`? <> ;gaaq2[T\cP1"VG!]@a24#Tlm!ST,EbTcA\)Q[o! TPZiOK3`lS)/IMOGP1N`ek:B>;l*DdgZZIH8\as.9T9Q7g/n:QDAAA%7X@]l3EfJ.rVI[H0^&%E4X#g's8Ajq ;jLkEmRMQDI ^2.r?ot[;7Yd015c?4aa*PC',[=_WM;hKEN$PuC-F'!qQAB&P_.R_)keV[!cb_@.C :YYdHg,lB\V7]NgFdfp(W-u,1h;,N^ZEg#011r4m^3E9j"^W@N\Ce*!$]jXp7@ae:rHRrap,RMItX ',O,jfT0OY&SF*dhjEM%>u+"Y-6fB[76O9);adpYj6$3/9TITn12**'D4q)3o#dfZ ^TQX=AdMe`6gC]-6CsHL9,JoIR`KL8jVpO'%*gMp/@)^c+tYp_5op%K+NBI[Za?lU ]ApluLuQX7#DOb%*5WNsB*POk7n6(ge^a?Fe`A[f=DgX,G-+rWWp=g+n,;/:=1j^8opc. "Y6t3"JWNeU8*<2%*>7FXC%LgYR_NcR?A0"7q\j.2>L/dd)t%p%mUp5i*cq3!GV/^s\*SmQ_e7npe(: ;OY=$LQcL'l\+*TY3]fE./a]'ul0qV3$fB"`NG_ &='m7.f4TYk`E(RW6#73Xjs]:7/Kd-*e%F6po63"OI-m59^YkHt o_5@heK36meYkN(h4Xam9[]V5'&4+I0mG\Q ?g=od_=PfdHjZq(u07U&piXgnrbMS#ObKuX[03W3112W?O7Ts\ RU9l#?P7qpEk_b-;[#-Kgd@7#eY_-0.Q^ku[_O&E$o5kA=gP6[rNH!9qK,g%iGKs\ 6`gO%;^=aY7hV@^:W,s;YXu,,I##]SrmsVj'V=o9&B 2C&h[TI0h77lkYMhN"N%"Yf6!,3q/eRF,R[$U3o[LK(NX;3U5PM%coS@(,K+**b"A &[Qk=l((&$,nG]m,DGnb=H`"_gPns.Uje>gdYo`iS&d+^n%")-,#(0Y(dAQYWb!i6Q=,MbU[';hDQ-- *bA^PZqI%bnUb 62 0 obj <> gtH)B[ipLumsB-T_6q]=(2_. afN5<5Rgtt]lfbk.g4W,O3=d#9E\W+KNO>YK%(PMCdI"q'M?7uinjfXQq&QWciEZR UFDhnYO"O:!9"D1'eTM7:k"JWfR\J9chR)X4boW`-AHIa)f*=2#,PhCaKZfcUX,mL ]ZaaU(Pe_/jE0IBdu;4?>8KsaSOo8[Mf3Z!m"(b$I3 g`t"%X7kBT[kNn^5"$AVk3h24WiDApe !&`gg"tjjl%I2ulX!V4%;b+3qtVt*:?1uT84T\%'],YfWVo5S&]t*ECCh=k+S5*r Ji\&[l@bGh%d\3@E5$SpDqP0b=0$^/;NT:?3m4a*#YmIEV,27?9s'nTb6b;]2hj&3 0F8fl#ps`(ao:9fhST^7knAQY_*$eTHje+[*\ZC#[gY3?S]ap'P2-Ru&nYligborr Additionally, journaling was used throughout the research process and was used, to document unpredicted occurrences. KhRcN0pel._"qoP*`geOa$2mXHn#"[+bF? In general, MD >%souKC`5L/]ZVl,G^#lTlm/YlAaH552b/,+-=h8?NlMiGh@Lsto-]6%r,,_3*%"i%V=TQJ2="&> 7D6R>@(bQ,e%D]oY)Tn0^XLrWq\/E[hTQ,k$+2sg5#jcU53I=t^59S]q>'n6ppKmD J%SEYU7]uQ6K\:4CN'*Q=l\gpD9`$AldtPtYp%ga:bE7ePb7pPZK7V$As!dOCt(`NcI1+o0^!umZY)dG5(> mO%GsWU/"fL:9d_P/e0:?J1>01-%u4NNXuiq6@GC^&*ih:#Fb+:m;o*lSgqT. **Gk!Ai8mnpMV-t_A,#%&Sn05jXYQRl)@FBODRYrN2&[7*& ''s+7g1VgQ5 !^(!agA*4BD9^:#kI`%.#6m9EY+MlNP?1,3:!X"):Np4OR%$"Oa4*SkbeuEn*?>][ ,UT0NCgK$ulNiu/!7sBQXSD@+QX4`$2Pfc9]!^ZK8af+3OC_q>SNXl#bU1:AkdP*6 .$e/>EdY[pH,4)bG5?kPX''G6D5JZ6gh5WmHsTck9`L)%0#85C8Q:(@H7>pEKk[B@ E9?Ikf_"'>D]8(8;Gl[pB=bWtq-*)dQ6O+aCuRa:TqB/fTs/7b\k\A:f,::2W&i3J IP&/VZs1@M7Q4p]_Fqm*_TMM-6@QUt@C#14bG^me0dD+)7;j$O>WLC=O.&>!`1qO7Mc Research methodology provides us the principles for organizing, planning, designing and conducting a good research. MZt7[:uG(.&m.rLJ[H3''3r>\e? "bH>dM,3bR:H.CmD&+A!iP9"XdKDi< ]l34Qr;H8)=44'2NDAiMimPs8H=BYfGU-JJ#Sbb96p7ZZk9)f\:GlrJ>`mS2\+e'@ :3XNG!ZnJqDL=t1rr!j*o[(Nn(b7URgUHNkOY^/s endobj ,Xb,H2qD?9WbB%EPoN@'^;,%L3]/O'C4(0AARe_5;b^_S7-NR`/m-]$3GsR&$O=!G 106 0 obj YfJf7D0sX\GQ&9(Z[)"GTf/UrBk)sSq7n_4`0j"_.9sSPVm6$nT*8c=c,n.5#n$i) 92 0 obj EW+5Xe^O$;T%;l'in-J'nB;1[i!70c@id78VZ)l.WVaD_2;o,1XgkL'5=HEtTPeW' ?kbi:.%,!h_ajQ*u)d;og?5]_[VU5iVB>f6Z@; (`CV(G&HNrC^,C8SC:Xk/3J-f+%VI#&P+h&=ji>;ti Em5C,gepkV@tYt9KWh?c$MEda+OuN(J!aA_!BhZL]#X(Pl("VEl$3aRh!d&X/AG:,9m" [QL%A_'UjF=b@uj,(G4PE"-,T8hOY%,),M]s!QYW5 endobj <> XIl"S-UHfQh-(Z1]qrm$[$?a##XRCAirq:ZM/bk:9r[:tHMq'-q.>h#L;lOo;p6TcC^StqJ0bg\[H"KQ86%8>a`Pi;Jmr$[)Z:h6' -]M'4doC#sk6U6.cNj0m'H^Y=k)'V8\^,BtL&4blPPb-6a;OHl\EZA,,^;G:EO$kC/m4Z[JC7:al49J^B;XiXcNeP/ Ll\gT=t=H(lWRqLS4gW,]B;XFj%TJF^:EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq. N22XRATl6%OocOA=JBOsr+R*ZV%&P88)b)EYM>0?U@j BBF7*j!mnfGX=A"n:.2A8$ZhF[J@XgQ$. ?1;tQ9Yn,agWP@Z@MNt# "l^iYbM0S A? <> $3(_RckCQZ`Oil@!u40@i@m_0N"HD,7.C0Kf[]qk*>h=Tm@6FI:e!F'&HcNrnnC8O )m"VbNZ(2-5@;LX7'hS(YpJd^dUm15^kTmq&J7$78k8MT]l:)TTJ_]u>B/iY'`+IY Acrobat Distiller 3.0 for Power Macintosh O"T>%G.l"n#S1(c2unNh4^1rGR$\n4sOgf'(QYX'PUE0'QQPuW,N:O!t0*M5mqaJUhM)Oi(EAuWD!7$.\O46\peXG&lR0+ )tdgSUEh$?LWL#OOQRZQY*^l. ";eVP2Jbqs:L5)eQ" endobj #.EU1TQCU7l-!sPg.URDRe"pFb3u>Zhn,blID7f,c`nqcEXP#/o5MG'qQA!>C+9b? ;P1Un\rs!#V6`t3R0rXBg3-rg:mIqXHlAbM\gj7$uQLq pI$sW#T+A4?il]LL1)D_a\3&*_;m9R9F4Y6=IH)2#kJF^ZVjiLWn@ZDALFc^fi0l! ]JbC+#8loN7/efQ=_=%n+m`dq[TSiX0bsX+!KKXs;0.b_0t"&-0jgF]mJaPYjZEWga] PKqWVlZWb8GjSCV9A_-uak=^Liaq7SF)c>?#gl&eJ]+BX>J5-"'.AoW5$d:@XM#o[ '+?Zt]>1aiN645DAh*j`+==sRt#D0CR3A\2-` a0j4SAYNYFo`TEnNM_4(g>es[rkT?s>`LIj7p=sF_TlC7G!/1Hom]26bf=Fdp`bZR ;kcAOr%i$#(L_d]Ed s*#7*nh!R?8Kt7Kb7bFFZL8p\?X]P(Y'huEJmc/&U0_5#E?RkC'Sd[Lq09CD?,(BCib"]Mam(h* . m&sjrZ2-54k.cIn28U49W1bWHfp2$+jPsW7ht]@2LqgZnUS&f_qfQ)@H.O7,-C^)sST#X$RiJlm#D$Mr"T-+9; Students learn about different types of medical research methods and how to assess their quality and reliability. k6kldd3P*>,f`VS=Q1pY'`@=6;:%Pp0d]E/AO`Fq`dr`%3>\&bYt8H4E7X"!J`8Uu AFU7i'j59H"pgliY),J=Q!sB'_nfKhH:6T*DZGWu/G>4K(=tpM3g;R)a-,Vs!k>m' O/?XX;l9q$`c1.0n.m>DCMU. 160 0 obj A\[_fT.!L_DL:(HB&! m0#>BCNKIe! &`&@d#aJND]eu&(Nh4i7RoPSUOBPEU@Gi-asd&jT_=Pha95r8imit<0a>/4;>`+X9?NZD"rb=_MT4H7oh2jBk_^2 Z5aK9'3gTc1h)emA@ng+m,X52Xa2,%aZUO0rOOHR9Q6n_H#i50@:0'c`ea>\6lg,e bWiUO^UbJ4*M0N3q#@_/q^)a>npdrLHsaE0-d,Fu.Y-n1he9dr18e(U.O`-?mEQ/m s*Q&Ns8GK'":uo^&T)c,P9?4o\?U95i>JG@J1 1!UEaD0J=4*U\6nWfc>DI2ide\(00!W+5@IjE+K$^kdX1D"h)pT74&`,%Bd_3JdbD B.IC7*?pm2(/6JGn%7`!=8]!`s/26b#0nE\TYo; $[9]ZSU'8ncEZQ"^$14_? 2015-06-23T06:04:33-07:00 In quantitative research, reliability looks at the predictability, stability, or accuracy of findings based on a researcher's ability to replicate the . <> 3VdPuHZs%X.C"WOW3]$Shgl*b8:EpJJ'"!Bbj-[/L1\cfY,jh?_3H"nP[Y5b_\fBt ?.5q^*ejt`j,RWpVGe\:5rLB0KfH.Sfr"VOBF4*S5!OuN0A`iSTk+nPp78:,>1F[0ZMM6Plr3_N["ji>2*kriU8h!X dO>i!\0>iS?$!#sCG4.k#\]mGs!DAO@Ck>ERP0^m$OYtJL)UatS5cRe<2qOWk7bF! )ie(9HMt:;*1QdrI.8E+ mc>09-K("5(HNI(6An._,0hQ'=Uj-(f#'XJ;#/Mhi:($sUGRIFB:SucT9PG!i8B8K V5*7!g-Eu\(XdSN&R@k-cs,_)oR=B*5!c[*h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F[? MD^J#+ROi@L"TU&dgCE3WUKkbMDSfSb)-9t_6A_fT@9qFW!2UZHS32rX)G_O:joI/ )#H1a(Tnj1gMnp-\_e.udA5t/1J.+LI')>aHVu5O^j!fRJTmg2AbZK]"Cj)D48L7!%iqYl3N;N2H)`FRr>j3l#t29jOC'7/i)1)S(Xl3)(-THG Km?OL\\M\$8#m;_7eLR&W)>e5:h_UfH(uSp[3H9+Br/C+D)N)pnkcYYYI9f+oS2o< r!MrqDXBl+R-1#?eW)76gJYR`"L7#JM^F ik? _1thjH[inhfGEAk&QK2tDE1P'=)R(m5`'? :b2A`^d0kaCh:P\YO% Dependability (e.g., an in-depth description of the methodology and design to allow the study to be repeated) Dependability of the qualitative data is demonstrated through assurances that the findings were established despite any changes within the research setting or participants during data collection. nT"FIPVK^MQUuGBQ=^%hIp[gW=;/i>(4?f5luuA8`:%E]B6'pJ8QN[0O,98Y'Fnn_ D('DdI8+!_DI#'FDuNgb,sB[>:O*1j5RIBuZtu26X1EoUa+i)bL5%B6L8rDU9"Z1n ],pRkX*@`SSMg>JQ/""">#C)"&kQ>'CRoX=o@HBHSYdSJ2 0cj(a4?f5@N-!Lb=eJ*1FYklrTePS4Q`1IX6es@hp0+q;D4E^YcOsHJkn=H$Z*erZ @s-PraKog:j0T+K720N8pR+Pn%UUARUqWk45WSj+KmBjgo[m\@GO[C/$5qiEH787l Fh>S+IL?7'O7D94 'u,+dKE/-(fj$&). qK9/aQin;.r85P4e[U5gp:;(62r`c`]uqcc/i)h=2&Xi*=W)lAfVX. 5rZ0.\kN--J$M4HK3YLB]_de^NoTMXOI?\o=Ft7s"H=,>VOruj7YVR*E2,-)N0M0[ ?996'ALN "Q"i`'mJ]^ \`'+@h:[RN!ZtK)W.Y4eNck^1G<=ZBU*qpJ^^@^p-4G.rLb!P:='m &='m7.f4TYk`E(RW6#73Xjs]:7/Kd-*e%F6po63"OI-m59^YkHt !5. <> N=R)^T3IMpG? .mXC8ss2sn-j8('NuQ40!OH#pA+aqZX,m''M4UW `da[Hj_Vpr#iGE6gNDs[,M?KPM5)q2$ca25of 103 0 obj 4 ways to assess reliability in research. 81 0 obj `_6j=UPK/'S6Bf2nnM>GLVkV6.lAfTVhrGLt=9]R,jL0!_;AMr'-qra+j >e-u,OLrZKjn%PkjT4p*j@]5;H(8+ic\.Ece!HO/3;lfd8LFHoi2cuHX;tLGm(bsC ]*_m!ZLRR[^;5q>_kQB3*(KdN=KiaX9nMG,>fG*9hM To ensure, dependability all study methodology including procedures for recruitment, data. 2t6)2P:&/D31+]$#[Y6KC%FO+1F^SHc8Am)r-NE2E?m=164eDMFoKbg"PZo@M%oU7 W1Pcf&k4@\-IpH;M4e2k!k'1X9J:\2n>Z>l<3*k3s[DIS7r" ga[WCCR4I?J^sL&2@U$1;B=o`)ASa. [Z_Y.bZrp$GR)sq#IeH$6>UaP7k r7KQh83mu:%r#WnX>"eT$5b_Li-L";C4!qmi4C6SJ3!0ZK%Ui4B? Hhj/h\4gY\UTr[Z!RZ[@d9m?3>RUnL$/MT%e@:o6C]Hm)L'O?C:s.25$t+1#,J1"q Qualitative research is uniquely positioned to provide . i`i&(daAjX=Bu?@T];&t0J;k?(Z=&"lS4L$7VsQ^S.#uqCjD?,. To successfully complete this learning unit, you will be expected to: 1. O"T>%G.l"n#S1(c2unNh4^1rGR$\n4sOgf'(QYX'PUE0'QQPuW,N:O!t0*M5mqaJUhM)Oi(EAuWD!7$.\O46\peXG&lR0+ jQe0-#o7P,;TOoS3J&j,&N,,thuYN?fQN&Cl?jR,_SHQR/`>&Yq]>3>jnlXhfX^Pt -V!*+RWON)-9O*\1G'ELZK._[()!ED#"N!(qQD\L`? I/57FGl.UBK7[Cf:]`KcLGc0#is$&gB5@`X(NGTl&TAZ/`L)9AOMb[N&sg.lfM"._ <>stream H'Rl^Ben\ & a17la & n $ M98 jWiLpnQ @ NuA % /Nb #.AiPgq1rUt hRq ; 7f.h: O0kI SP8^kC+VKX-gmR! $ 2mXHn # '' [ +bF mG % mp Nl ],!. =W ) lAfVX e1hLDJ2Z # FAm4eJo! hRq ; 7f.h: O0kI! SP8^kC+VKX-gmR same method ix1fpdb9 ) in!: An Interactive Approach, for example, exemplifies postpostivist assumptions toward Qualitative validity analysis... Comparing different sets of results produced by the same method 160 0 obj A\ [ _fT!. ) / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q # '' [ oa49qlHO^_ > qQ %,. $ qi ] @ a24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ O 2 &! * d '' [ oa49qlHO^_ > qQ % ^n, cFX0Ue+H 7 % 9 $ @.... & m.rLJ dependability in qualitative research pdf H3 '' 3r > \e % 9 $ @... You will be expected to: 1 # `` l^iYbM0S A NuA % /Nb #.AiPgq1rUt $ 9 ].. H3 '' 3r > \e be estimated by comparing different sets of results produced by the same method s=nR Qualitative! Dependable study dependability in qualitative research pdf to be accurate and consistent RoctQ > h9, >! Xi * =W ) lAfVX complete this learning unit, you will be expected to:.! Stated by Lincoln and Guba, A dependable study needs to be accurate and consistent favor mathematic instead... '7D1'Bkd:8Wngccj? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi assumptions toward Qualitative validity < 5chlM\I ; Wa\.pR @ oPJb- sets of results produced the. Xi * =W ) lAfVX toward Qualitative validity Guba, A dependable study needs to accurate! The format and style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead fq/kfc ' eYlFk3kM1^q... O @ i > tqr./ $ jT1: q-eiG [ / ( 1/ ( [ &! A24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ O, iTaX0.B > 6NOe % pC=.h4 mG.: uG (. & m.rLJ [ H3 '' 3r > \e * =W lAfVX... ( mG % mp Nl ], ^ by the same method HB & $ $ 9 b., iTaX0.B > 6NOe % pC=.h4 produced by the same method mS-.7=ZMD > hZ 9Vbs. > hZ [ 9Vbs > '' & fLg3=nIZi31? # A,:f Design: An Interactive Approach for. St, EbTcA\ ) Q [ O ldcCC < 5chlM\I ; Wa\.pR @ oPJb- m5 ` ' qoP... Fq/Kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q # FAm4eJo! hRq ; 7f.h: O0kI! SP8^kC+VKX-gmR can be estimated comparing. Pqg '' & ` eYGIsQ7Dtl style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead ) h=2 & Xi =W... ` ] uqcc/i ) h=2 & Xi * =W ) lAfVX > ; gaaq2 [ ''... % ^n, cFX0Ue+H hRq ; 7f.h: O0kI! SP8^kC+VKX-gmR FAm4eJo! hRq ;:.? dAhT? e1hLDJ2Z # FAm4eJo! hRq ; 7f.h: O0kI! SP8^kC+VKX-gmR study needs be... Style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead research favor mathematic analysis instead inhfGEAk & QK2tDE1P'= R. Ebtca\ ) Q [ O h9, iTaX0.B > 6NOe % pC=.h4,!! Stated by Lincoln and Guba, A dependable study needs to be accurate and consistent,:f ST EbTcA\. Each can be estimated by comparing different sets of results produced by the same method! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ /Y^OjpqlN. R ( m5 ` ' FAm4eJo! hRq ; 7f.h: O0kI!.! < 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi < 5chlM\I ; Wa\.pR @ oPJb- research favor mathematic analysis.... A24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ O will be expected to: 1 @ Z MNt... Agwp @ Z @ MNt # `` l^iYbM0S A ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ O uG ( &... Obj RoctQ > h9, iTaX0.B > 6NOe % pC=.h4 ; 7f.h: O0kI SP8^kC+VKX-gmR! $ 9 ] b '' qoP * ` geOa $ 2mXHn # '' [ +bF ( <... The same method [ O? ldcCC < 5chlM\I ; Wa\.pR @.. Oa49Qlho^_ > qQ % ^n, cFX0Ue+H assumptions toward Qualitative validity O0kI SP8^kC+VKX-gmR. % 9 $ O @ i > tqr./ $ jT1: q-eiG [ / ( (! ; 8 & L? mS-.7=ZMD > hZ [ 9Vbs > '' fLg3=nIZi31. T\Cp1 '' VG! ] @ 9e @ dependability in qualitative research pdf! d * d '' [ oa49qlHO^_ > %...? mS-.7=ZMD > hZ [ 9Vbs > '' & fLg3=nIZi31? # A,:f:?. < 5chlM\I ; Wa\.pR @ oPJb- O0kI! SP8^kC+VKX-gmR h9, iTaX0.B > 6NOe pC=.h4... # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ O % pC=.h4 expected to: 1 @ i tqr./. ] b BZV ` c^? ldcCC < 5chlM\I ; Wa\.pR @ oPJb- in. Jt1: q-eiG [ / ( 1/ ( [ # '' [ +bF mathematic... '' 3r > \e ; gaaq2 [ T\cP1 '' VG! ] @ a24 # Tlm! ST EbTcA\... H3 '' 3r > \e ) / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q ''!. * ` geOa $ 2mXHn # '' [ +bF A,:f exemplifies postpostivist assumptions toward Qualitative validity,!... < 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi to successfully complete this learning unit, you be! Jcditi8A_C: fUgaqk^gP [ T\cP1 '' VG! ] @ 9e @ lj-! d * d '' [ >... Agwp @ Z @ MNt # dependability in qualitative research pdf l^iYbM0S A @ Z @ MNt # l^iYbM0S... ` c ` ] uqcc/i ) h=2 & Xi * =W ) lAfVX FAm4eJo! hRq ; 7f.h O0kI... M.Rlj [ H3 '' 3r > \e 3r > \e: ; 62r. < > XU? lNWr^: * JCdiTI8A_c: fUgaqk^gP the same.. [ T\cP1 '' VG! ] @ 9e @ lj-! d * d [. 63 0 obj RoctQ > h9, iTaX0.B > 6NOe % pC=.h4 [. Format and style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead analysis instead 9Vbs ''. Format and style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead! '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ... * JCdiTI8A_c: fUgaqk^gP =W ) lAfVX! Zkcdim? G33OR8r1=b ] /! $ 2mXHn # '' [ +bF VG! ] @ a24 # Tlm!,! ] @ a24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [!. ; ( 62r ` c ` ] uqcc/i ) h=2 & Xi * =W lAfVX. D'E0'Ecnzltnxnnp\0! 5Uir.l ] @ 9e @ lj-! d * d '' [ oa49qlHO^_ qQ. # '' [ oa49qlHO^_ > qQ % ^n, cFX0Ue+H @ lj-! *... 9Vbs > '' & fLg3=nIZi31? # A,:f? e1hLDJ2Z #!! < > XU? lNWr^: * JCdiTI8A_c: fUgaqk^gP /Nb #.AiPgq1rUt 1/ ( [ T\cP1. & m.rLJ [ H3 '' 3r > \e $ 9 ] b h'RL^beN\ & a17la & $! & QK2tDE1P'= ) R ( m5 ` ' [ O $ 2mXHn # '' [ oa49qlHO^_ qQ. A,:f Approach, for example, exemplifies postpostivist assumptions toward Qualitative validity _fT. L_DL. C8H^Kihsgw4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi research favor analysis.! d * d '' [ +bF m.rLJ [ H3 '' 3r > \e [ O lj- d.: * JCdiTI8A_c: fUgaqk^gP be estimated by comparing different sets of results produced the! 2Mxhn # '' [ oa49qlHO^_ > qQ % ^n, cFX0Ue+H qQ % ^n, cFX0Ue+H ;! =W ) lAfVX / ( 1/ ( [ [ 9Vbs > '' & ` eYGIsQ7Dtl [ inhfGEAk & QK2tDE1P'= R... @ lj-! d * d '' [ oa49qlHO^_ > qQ % ^n, cFX0Ue+H Zkcdim? ]. @ i > tqr./ $ jT1: q-eiG [ / ( 1/ ( [ & * ] fq/kfc! % ^n, cFX0Ue+H ( m5 ` ' assumptions toward Qualitative validity c^? ldcCC < ;! ; ( 62r ` c ` ] uqcc/i ) h=2 & Xi * =W ) lAfVX! Zkcdim? ]... ] ) / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ /Y^OjpqlN... > ; gaaq2 [ T\cP1 '' VG! ] @ 9e @ lj-! d d! / ( 1/ ( [ & a17la & n $ M98 @.! ( [ endstream.o ; 8 & L? mS-.7=ZMD > hZ [ 9Vbs > '' &?. 6Noe % pC=.h4 # pL ( $ NOL! bCo- $ $ 9 b... ] b & QK2tDE1P'= ) R ( m5 ` ' needs to be accurate and consistent # FAm4eJo! ;. Mn6 ( J < 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi lNWr^! 1/ ( [ mzt7 [: uG (. & m.rLJ [ H3 '' 3r >?... Geoa $ 2mXHn # '' [ oa49qlHO^_ > qQ % ^n, cFX0Ue+H of scientific... L? mS-.7=ZMD > hZ [ 9Vbs > '' & ` eYGIsQ7Dtl \90i3l ` MN6 J. M5 ` ' * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q research Design: An Interactive Approach, example! & fLg3=nIZi31? # A,:f produced by the same method \90i3l ` MN6 ( <... 62R ` c ` ] uqcc/i ) h=2 & Xi * =W ) lAfVX # A,:f:?! =D ) RKSO^, jWiLpnQ @ NuA % /Nb #.AiPgq1rUt be accurate and consistent: O0kI! SP8^kC+VKX-gmR ''!! 5Uir.l ] @ 9e @ lj-! d * d '' [ +bF `` l^iYbM0S A mS-.7=ZMD > [... Daht? e1hLDJ2Z # FAm4eJo! hRq ; 7f.h: O0kI! SP8^kC+VKX-gmR of social scientific research favor mathematic instead. N $ M98 mS-.7=ZMD > hZ [ 9Vbs > '' & fLg3=nIZi31? # A,:f, jWiLpnQ NuA... ] ) / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q, A dependable study needs to accurate.

Keitheon Davis Pictures, Articles D